Strategy Index Volume 2: Who's On First

Play ball! Then talk about it. Or vice versa.
Post Reply
User avatar
TheLegend
Babe Ruth
Posts: 719
Joined: Mon Jan 31, 2005 11:15 am
Location: Oakland, duh.
Contact:

Strategy Index Volume 2: Who's On First

Post by TheLegend »

I was going to talk about both of the corner infield positions in this article, but then I got to thinking about the way I play firstbase compared to how others defend the position and decided that I have an unusual view of it. So, in that light I will devote this entire article to sharing my perspective and experience of defending the "luke warm corner".

The 1.5Baseman

Anyone who was paying any attention to me at firstbase a couple of weeks ago (probably no one) would have noticed that I play WAY off the line- almost halfway to second base. I try to place myself at the end of the second baseman's range and consider any ball hit to my right to be the his play. I also "lean on" or anticipate the ball hit to my left which allows me to adequitely defend the line. I do this because I don't want to have to move to my right to defend any balls, knowing that my foremost responsibility is covering firstbase (which is to my left) for the throw. As it is obviously harder to change directions than it is to run in one direction, I like to position myself in such a way that I never have to (attempt to)field a ball hit to my right, and then change directions and sprint back to cover first base. From where I set up on the field, the entirety of my "territory" or defensive zone is to my left, which means that I will never have to move right and then switch directions.

The exception to this rule is the 3-6-1 double play ball hit between me and the second baseman. On this ball, my momentum (from moving to my right to field the ball) will make for an easier throw to second, but note that I still won't have to double back (which as stated before, is my main concern) as in this situation it is the pitcher's job to cover firstbase.

The Basics
Ok, so now that I've gotten my personal heresy and conjecture out of the way, we can move on to the way "the experts" say to play first base.

The most common mistake I see our firstbasemen make is holding the bag on a misthown ball and watching as the ball rolls past them or sails over their head. A few times I've seen Anthony do a great job of coming off the bag to field the bad throw and then going for the tag to get the out. Firstbasemen have to remember that a throw that goes over your head is an automatic base. It's much better to come off the bag and not get the out than it is to insist on staying on the bag, not get the out and allow all the runners to move up 90 feet. You have to be able to judge the ball as it approaches and make the decision whether it will be high or off target, if it is- abandon the base and concentrate on keeping the ball in front of you.

The Bag
On any ball hit on the ground (with the exception of the ball hit to the first baseman) the first baseman should sprint to first base, plant his foot on the edge of the bag (a lot easier with 3-dimentional bases, but you get the idea) put his glove out and look for the throw. The foot on the bag should never move unless the throw is off target (think of the way you plant your back foot in the batter's box) as moving your back foot is an easy way to lose track of the base which may allow the batter to reach. With our flat bases, there really is no "edge" so the rule should be that the inside half of the base belongs to the fielder and the outside half (toward foul territory) belongs to the runner. A lot of times there will be collisions or crushed toes if either the first baseman or the hitter (or both) try to control too much of the base.

The Stretch

This one's simple, but often overlooked. DON'T STRETCH UNTIL THE BALL IS IN THE AIR. If you stretch for the ball before you know exactly where it's going you can take yourself out of position. It will make it much harder for you to field a throw that is basically on target, but doesn't go exactly where you expect. Don't stretch until the ball is in the air and you can accurately judge where it will be.

When stretching remember not to move your back leg, but to move your front leg and glove hand (both are left for right handed throwers and right for left handed throwers) as far as you can (hence the term "stretch") so you catch the ball as early as possible. The quality of a stretch can easily be the difference between an infield hit and a ground out.

The Scoop

The hardest throw to field for a first baseman is the one that bounces right as it gets to you. There are two ways to increase your chances of fielding this ball cleanly.

The easier way is to shorten your stretch and catch the ball as it bounces up. This is generally effective, but every now and then the ball will skid or take a bad bounce, which could lead to the ball getting past you.

I prefer to hold my position and widen my glove as much I can, listening and feeling for the ball to hit it, and then close on the ball (much like fielding a batted ground ball). Remember to let the ball come to you and not to swipe at it, i.e. keep your body still as the ball approaches. Not only does swiping at the ball make it harder to catch it, but it also makes in easier for the ball to pop out at the top of your swipe.
==

Yup. I'm the bomb. I left out the section about warming up the infield, because I feel like that's pretty self explanitory, but I still feel like there may be something else I'm forgetting about. Feel free to comment, add or subtract as you see fit.

Next week: The Hot Corner: Where the real ballers play 8)
User avatar
TheLegend
Babe Ruth
Posts: 719
Joined: Mon Jan 31, 2005 11:15 am
Location: Oakland, duh.
Contact:

Post by TheLegend »

I said! Feel free to comment damnit!
User avatar
Baseball=Life
Baseball Deity
Posts: 1031
Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2005 11:16 pm
Location: SF, CA

1st Base

Post by Baseball=Life »

That was a pretty thorough description of expectations of First Basemen. Not really appropriate for your column, but I'll point out that 1st Basemen are expected to carry offensive weight for a team when at the plate. Giants and A's fans don't let JT Snow or Scott Hatteberg confuse you---these guys are great with the glove but lack woefully at the plate. (Note: don't let this thread become a debate about those guys, it's just an example. Take your debate on that to the MLB forum.)

Of course, if we allow bunts, that will involve the 1st basemen rushing in if the ball is bunted down the 1st baseline.

I think one thing that all infielders must do is just be prepared for what to do in every scenario. I remember once I saw Andres Gallaraga make a play at first where, with a runner on third, he speared a one-hop liner to his right (2nd baseside), close to the ground. He immediately kept his spin momentum going in a 360 back to 1st base. He planted his left foot on the bag and then used it to push off and gun the throw home. He nailed the runner by a small margin at the plate, because he had kept moving the entire time. He never lost momentum because he knew exactly where he was going to finish the double play. So first basemen, even when big guys (as they often are) like Andres Gallagraga, can make those defensive gems, especially when they tighten up every aspect of the play in their minds before-hand.

Other issues that effect First Basemen come into play when a ball is hit in foul territory on the 1st Baseside. Unless it's a pop-up in front of them, they might have to turn away from home plate and run, and then re-locate that ball once they've stopped in the general vicinity they think it's going to land. Only run while looking up (or run backwards for that matter) when it's hit lightly enough to warrent that. Quite frequently, you'll have to turn and run, then relocate. This is especially relevant to our field at DeFremery, where we have ample foul territory. And if a runner is on 2nd or 3rd when you make that catch, be prepared to make a strong throw to home or 3rd to prevent that runner from tagging up. They'll be tempted to because you're so out of position in foul territory.

Similar to the above situation is when a line drive or ground ball is hit to your left down the 1st baseline and you manage to deflect it or get your glove to slow it down... When you run after the ball to retrieve it, have one thing in mind... making a nice underhand throw to the pitcher covering first. This is tricky because the pitcher will be a moving target. Aim for chest-high above the base--let the pitcher get to the ball. Don't try to throw to him away from the base, assuming he'll be able to catch it and then locate the bag. You want to save him from doing that by letting him focus almost entirely on finding that bag (and avoiding the runner, for that matter), so a good easy throw is crucial in that situation.

Well that's all I can think of for now. Again, great post Kenyatte.
"Baseball is like church, many attend, few understand"

- Leo Durocher
User avatar
TheLegend
Babe Ruth
Posts: 719
Joined: Mon Jan 31, 2005 11:15 am
Location: Oakland, duh.
Contact:

Post by TheLegend »

Very good points Scott!
User avatar
retep
Player/Manager
Posts: 1043
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 9:02 am
Location: Berkeley
Contact:

Re: 1st Base

Post by retep »

Baseball=Life wrote:t I'll point out that 1st Basemen are expected to carry offensive weight for a team when at the plate.


Even putting the A's and Giants aside, I would say that this is no longer ture. The recent trent seems to be the OFs carrying the team. i.e. Bonds, Beltran, Wells, Sheffield, Ramírez, Drew, Gonzo, Anderson, Ichiro, Berkman, Bay, Guerrero, Andruw & Chipper Jones and so forth.

I can only think of a few 1Bs that carry the team.... Thome, Sexon (when healthy), Bagwell, Palmeiro, and Hillenbrand (maybe).

The 1B is the anchor of the infield. I can almost see a good 1B acting nearly like the C to the pitcher, or, a better example, the CF of the infield.
User avatar
gohlkus
Player/Manager
Posts: 257
Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2005 7:02 pm
Location: Madison, WI
Contact:

Post by gohlkus »

To amplify:

Get out of my way when I'm coming down the first base line. Next time I'm not going to slow down when the ENTIRE BAG IS COVERED UP BY A CROUCHING FIRST BASEMAN -- I'm just going to plow into you.

"The Legend" makes a good point -- leave me at least one half of the base so that I can step on it and keep running. One is supposed to be able to run through first.
User avatar
retep
Player/Manager
Posts: 1043
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 9:02 am
Location: Berkeley
Contact:

Post by retep »

Sometimes, however, the first baseman has a simple goal: must find bag. On the play you are referring to, I had no clue where the bag was, and I made a point of trying to simply reach it. This was expressed in the form of an ugly half-dive, which resulted in us both getting clomped.

For the record, you DID just plow into me that time, so nothing new :)

And I am sorry for that. Remember, I don't wanna get hurt either. However, you need to understand that it can become part of the game: we each have our goals.
User avatar
Southpaw Slim
Kenesaw Mountain Landis
Posts: 610
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 7:36 pm
Location: Oakland, CA
Contact:

Post by Southpaw Slim »

retep wrote:I can only think of a few 1Bs that carry the team.... Thome, Sexon (when healthy), Bagwell, Palmeiro, and Hillenbrand (maybe).
Peter, are you out of your mind? I was in Scott's fantasy league last year, and one thing I remember was the surplus of good first basemen. There are much better 1Bs than those guys.

What about Overbay? Delgado? Helton? Pujols?! Are you going to tell me those guys can't crush a few? There is definitely an expectation for a first baseman to produce. Snow is an exeption because of his defense, and Hatteberg for his plate discipline.
I intended to write something to remind everybody of my superior prowess.
User avatar
AntMoOAK
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 5:43 pm
Location: The 'Town
Contact:

Post by AntMoOAK »

Hey guys great posts and responses... I look forward to reading about the other positions especially the middle infield where I feel and look about as silly as I imagine Martha Stewart would look in a Jennifer Lopez choreographed dance video.

A coupla' points... I was always taught ( like Ken said) to find the EDGE of the bag with your plant foot. After so many practices, you learn to go to the bag and slide your foot against the side of the bag instictively much like how Shaq knows where he is in the post with is back turned to the basket. HOWEVER, even though I have been playing 1st base since high school (after being usurped from centerfield by an Oakland Babe Ruth league All-Star), I find that no matter where I am in the field, I cannot find the base if it is not a bag and sometimes INADVERDANTLY, I have found myself wrongly in the runner's way. Dave ( I think) running me over last game comes to mind. One thing I've done to try and alleviate that is to between innings, drag my self two lines on the infield. One that runs from the middle ofthe 1st base position to about 3 feet from the bag where a draw another line across the othre line so that I know where I am with no bag to feel for. I know it's cheap and it has a WTF is he doing response, but it has helped find the base without being in the runners way. Playing softball and baseball in casual settings I have had my share of ".... his foot wasn't on the base..." calls that I thought were cheap and lacked the foresight of safety. It has always been my wish that the runner could run to the outside of 1st and not necessarily to the bag. Much like in softball where a runner coming home runs behind the plate with the understanding that the first base "bag" is extended (only a foot or so). I cringe to see when someone steps on the firstbase man and the runner rolls his ankle.
User avatar
gohlkus
Player/Manager
Posts: 257
Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2005 7:02 pm
Location: Madison, WI
Contact:

Post by gohlkus »

It's true -- no one wants to get hurt. Though it may have seemed like I just plowed into you, Peter, I actually slowed down as I approached... in order to reduce the potential impact. Just imagine if I were to not slow down next time.... :)

I do have to remember that even though I'm "entitled" to a path to the base, it's not easy to find those bases, and they move around a lot.


Also, Mientkiewicz was an exception for a while, but the Twins decided his consistent brilliance in the field just didn't make up for his inconsistency at the plate.
User avatar
retep
Player/Manager
Posts: 1043
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 9:02 am
Location: Berkeley
Contact:

Post by retep »

what worked for the Giants for the longets time was that we had Kent, who went above and beyond a 2B's offesnive duties. With that, the Giants could trade off having an offensively sup-par 1B.
Post Reply